Logo
Umatilla

New construction homes for sale in Umatilla, FL

48 homes

New home communities in Umatilla, FL

2 communities

  1. Jome
  2. New homes search
  3. Florida
  4. Gainesville–Ocala Area
  5. Lake County
  6. Umatilla

Housing market in Umatilla, FL

  • State
    Florida
  • Market
    Gainesville-Ocala Area
  • Neighborhoods
    0
  • Communities
    2
  • Single family
    49
  • Townhouses
    0
  • Multi family
    0
  • Condominiums
    0
  • Active builders
    2
  • Starting price
    $284,990
  • Median price
    $349,900
  • Price per square foot
    $211.54

Real estate price trends

Home price data reflects 48 listings in Umatilla, FL, sourced from Jome and updated regularly

*Based on Jome markets

What it's like to live in Umatilla?

The Local Vibe (Location & Identity)

Located in northern Lake County, Umatilla serves as the southern gateway to the Ocala National Forest. This community of approximately 5,300 residents maintains a rural identity centered on agriculture and outdoor recreation. While it sits about 50 miles north of Orlando, the local economy is driven by the school district and regional nurseries rather than urban sprawl.

Living Here: Amenities & Lifestyle

Daily life here revolves around the water and the woods. Residents frequently gather at North Lake Community Park, which offers expansive sports fields and walking trails. For those who enjoy the water, the public boat ramps on Lake Eustis are just a short drive south. Weekend excursions often lead into the Ocala National Forest for hiking or camping at Alexander Springs. Local shopping is concentrated along State Road 19, serving the immediate needs of the community. While the commute to major employment hubs in Orlando can exceed an hour, you will find several new home communities in Umatilla that cater to those seeking a slower pace.

Schools & Family Appeal

Families are served by the Lake County School District, with Umatilla Elementary, Middle, and High Schools all located within the city limits. These campuses act as central gathering points for local sports and community events. The Umatilla Public Library also provides a consistent schedule of youth programming and educational resources.

Why New Construction Makes Sense Here

Much of the existing housing stock in this area consists of older ranch-style homes or rural properties that may require significant updates to roofing and HVAC systems. Choosing new construction homes in Umatilla provides immediate peace of mind through 10-year structural warranties and modern building codes designed for Florida’s humid subtropical climate. Buyers can avoid the immediate capital expenditures often associated with older Lake County properties, such as aging septic systems or outdated electrical panels. For those on a tighter timeline, quick move-in homes in Umatilla offer the benefit of a brand-new build without the standard construction wait. This reliability is particularly valuable in a region where specialized contractors can be harder to schedule than in the metro core.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What is the current median sale price for a property in Umatilla, FL?

The Umatilla, FL presents a median sale price of $361,945 for properties, based on the most recent data from December 2025. This figure encompasses 46 new construction homes, each representing the vision of one of 2 innovative builders in the region.

Who are the major developers of new construction homes in Umatilla, FL?

Umatilla, FL's real estate market offers many new construction options, with D.R. Horton and Richmond American Homes as the main developers. These builders create communities suited to modern living.